The Student News Site of The Webb Schools

Webb Canyon Chronicle
The Student News Site of The Webb Schools

Webb Canyon Chronicle
The Student News Site of The Webb Schools

Webb Canyon Chronicle
Categories:

Super Bowl Halftime performers are selling out

Patrick Dóñez, Staff Writer
February 3, 2019
NFL players have been protesting the national anthem for over a year by kneeling or raising fists. Graphic courtesy of Patrick Dóñez (’21)

The Super Bowl is one of the country’s most widely viewed television events. Over the last few years, the NFL has faced constant criticism because of its handling of social justice issues such as police brutality and domestic violence. The league hoped that the final game of the season would be free of controversy, but the halftime show, what is supposed to be the most lighthearted part of the evening, is a matter of intense debate.

Super Bowl 53’s halftime show will be headlined by pop-rock band Maroon 5 and rappers Travis Scott and Big Boi. Their choice to perform has been widely criticized. One Change.org petition for Maroon 5 to drop the show has over 110,000 signatures. Artists like Rihanna, Jay-Z, and Meek Mill refused to perform in solidarity with Kaepernick, and have asked their colleagues to do the same.

It seems that by showcasing black artists like Scott, the NFL is pandering to fans who support Kaepernick. Scott was able to get the league to match his $500k donation to Dream Corps, a non-profit that champions social justice causes, but throwing money at the issues Kaepernick supports will not solve the NFL’s problems.

If commissioner Roger Goodell and the team owners really cared about the issues important to the players, they would not need massive backlash to make a change. The same is true of Scott, Big Boi, and even Maroon 5. If they really stand with Kaepernick and other players, they would not stand with NFL.

To say that the NFL has had a bad few years would be an understatement. Debilitating head injuries, inconsistent officiating, and a startling lack of diversity amongst coaches and executivescall plague the league. What is worse is that this controversy has raged for the better part of a decade. Then, in 2016, Colin Kaepernick ignited the sports world by refusing to stand for the national anthem. This decision made a huge impact on Kaepernick’s career and sparked a national discussion around police brutality, patriotism, the military, and activism in the workplace.

When asked in a postgame interview to explain his decision to sit for the anthem during the San Francisco 49ers’ preseason game, Kaepernick said “I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color. To me, this is bigger than football and it would be selfish on my part to look the other way.” He went on to argue that to him, the American flag was a symbol of oppression, particularly police brutality. Kaepernick was soon joined by teammate Eric Reid in kneeling for the anthem, and before long, dozens of professional athletes were kneeling or linking arms in solidarity with their colleagues.

On March 3rd, 2017, Kaepernick officially opted out of his contract with the 49ers, expecting to be released anyway, and began to look for a new job in the NFL as a free agent. Based solely on his production on the football field, he should definitely be employed by now, at least as a backup quarterback. Of the 47 quarterbacks who started a game in 2017, only 16 outperformed Kaepernick in terms of quarterback rating, leading many to believe that he is being kept out of the league in retaliation for his protests. Public figures from NFL owners to President Trump have been critical of the protests, calling them disruptive, unpatriotic, and disrespectful to the flag and military.

But Colin Kaepernick is right. The NFL is a league with a 70%  black player-base, where less than 20% of the coaches and front office executives are black. It is known for being especially insensitive to issues of diversity, player safety, or social issues like domestic violence.

The league takes millions of dollars from the Department of Defense every year to perform exaggerated displays of coercive patriotism and “flag-kissing.” Meanwhile, Kaepernick has raised and donated millions of dollars to charities benefiting communities of color and created awareness for often overlooked social issues.

Kaepernick should be an NFL quarterback, and he is not, which brings us to the 2019 Super Bowl.  Maroon 5, Travis Scott, and Big Boi should never have accepted the invitation to perform, but if they support Kaepernick and the issues he stands for, they should use the platform to make a statement.

View Story Comments
Print this Story
More to Discover
More in Opinion
Maddie Leiva (‘27) and Gavin Hamilton (‘27) dramatically pose while holding signs promoting the democratic and republican parties respectively. The two students are both expressing dismay for each other's signs, however situations such as this disagreement are encouraged at Webb. “It's important to keep people in your life that you disagree with, because it kind of affirms what you really believe in,” Saraya Chigoji (‘27) said. Moments of debate build stronger individuals who can allow political differences to coexist.
Webb undermines political diversity
Chappell Roan has not only found herself in the spotlight of fame, but also in the spotlight of controversy. Her push to ask questions and truly learn about candidates has ignited intense debate amongst voters and fans or hers. “People were pushing her to vote for Kamala Harris but Chappell was pushing for proper research and authenticity, which is far more important than a presidential campaign, in my opinion,” said Emily Thornton (‘25).
Chappell Roan and nuance — why we need civil discourse
Former VWS student Mia Li (’27) and WSC student Albert Luo (’27) found themselves disagreeing over whether to bring snacks to their club meeting. The seemingly trivial disagreement soon escalated into a two-sided fight, where they each firmly held on to their beliefs. “Albert is just difficult,” said Mia Li (’27) with a grin.
Why we cannot talk: gender polarization and its echo chambers
A pathway illuminated only by car lights is met with the sight of the locked DSPL gate. Forced to sit in their car as they waited for security to open the gate. “One time it was closed in the morning when I had to go to school, so I had to call,” Jasmine Beseth (‘25) said. “Sometimes the issue is just that they're like, not there to open it.” In this photo for example, it took security a long time to open the gate as they were not present at their stand and had no gate opener on hand.
Webb needs better safety precautions
The Less Perry Gym during afternoon activity. The ceiling with no windows or air conditioning shows the lack of ventilation in the building. "During the summer practices, I've been to practice, it would kind of be hotter inside the gym than outside the gym,” said Nate Llorens (‘27).
The Les Perry Gymnasium needs air conditioning
Homecoming proposals at Webb have significantly declined in creativity in recent years. From underwater to La La Land-themed asks, students should continue the level of effort that has been put into these proposals in the past. “I think the best proposals are ones that include the interests of the other person and spin it creatively like we have seen at Webb in the past,” Caitlin Delgado (’25) said.
Webb Homecoming proposals lack creativity
About the Contributor
Patrick Dóñez
Patrick Dóñez, Editor-in-Chief
Patrick Dóñez (’21), a day student from Upland, California, is one of this year's editors in chief. Last year, Patrick was the Editor of Opinion, which helped the transition into his leadership role for the 2020 – 2021 school year.  This year, he wants the WCC to lead conversations about different political and social topics in the Webb community. He enjoys listening to hip hop and RnB, and some of his favorite artists are Pusha T, Erykah Badu, and Modest Mouse. Patrick enjoys writing about his opinions and music, which is why joining journalism in sophomore year was perfect for him. During quarantine, he spent most of his time reading, skateboarding, and working on his magazine project Rx. After COVID-19, he is excited to finally get out of the house and nervous for the future of college and higher education.