Whether Impossible State is possible?

Victoria Liu, Editor of News and Opinion

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Passionate about nuclear dynamics in the Korean peninsula, I checked out a new work titled The Impossible State: North Korea, Past and Future by Victor Cha. He is the former Director of Asian Affairs in the White House’s National Security Council and top adviser on North Korea under the presidency of President George H. Bush.

This work, published in 2012, comes from Victor Cha’s diplomatic experience as a representative of the Six Party Talks. He details the United States’ foreign policies against North Korea and neighbors, economic policies, and the nuclear dynamics of North Korea.

Victor Cha criticizes the dominant representation of American policies against North Korea in mainstream media. From his perspective, mainstream media portrays the United States as taking a hardline stance against North Korea, cornering North Korea to a weak position. It would seem that nuclear weapons are its only option.

But, Victor Cha makes the case that the United States has sustained over twenty years of diplomacy to denuclearize North Korea. As Cha recounts, “…the result is that any additional American flexibility is widely perceived in the region as evidence of American leadership, but is viewed in Washington as a combination of desperation and weakness.”

His diplomatic experience intrigues me. Although President Bush labeled North Korea as a country on the “axis of evil” along with Iran and Iraq, representatives like Cha continued to engage in productive dialogues with North Korea, South Korea, China, Russia, and Japan. These dialogues constitute The Six Party Talks, which focused on the denuclearization of North Korea. The talks partially succeeded in 2006 when North Korea halted its nuclear plants in Yongbyon.

Cha leaves the audience to ponder, “whether or not the North Korea’s nuclear weapons threat can be blamed on the U.S. unwillingness to negotiate with a rogue regime.”

Victor Cha’s analysis of North Korea’s neighbors is impressive. One of the most interesting arguments in the book is how China has an ulterior mercantilist motive in North Korea. With “an overwhelming 41 percent of Chinese joint ventures in North Korea… in extractive industries,” China’s economy relies on rare earth minerals, iron, and steel, and other extractive enterprises in North Korea.  Underlying China’s ambivalence towards North Korea is an economic motive.

North Korea just fired a long-range ballistic missile on November 28, 2017. On December 10th, President Trump publicly nominated Victor Cha as the Ambassador to South Korea and is currently waiting for Seoul’s approval. Clearly, Cha’s views in The Impossible State: North Korea, Past and Future will be much more relevant in this age.

About the Writer
Victoria Liu, Editor of News & Opinion

Victoria Liu (‘18) is the Editor of News and Opinion at the Webb Canyon Chronicle. Born in Sydney, Australia, she lived and studied in Beijing, China, until she came to Webb as a new sophomore. Victoria is a member of the Honor Cabinet, responsible for holding disciplinary hearings and promoting a honor-based community. Not only is she the captain of the Webb debate team, but also she runs the Political Union club and spends her free time playing golf. Victoria joined Journalism to express her opinions to the Webb community. She has a passion for politics, international relations, and history, and she looks forward to sharing her unique perspectives through her writing.

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Opinion

    VWS and WSC, divided or united? (Chapter 1)

  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Columns

    Column: Centenary of World War I

  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Opinion

    Should Webb have a cheer team?

  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Opinion

    For the culture, or for the point?

  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Opinion

    Kavanaugh: Good news or bad news?

  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Opinion

    On the topic of Saturday the 28th

  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Columns

    Column: Is bias bad?

  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Opinion

    Editorial: Why we write our names alongside our work

  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Opinion

    Progress reports are useful: always, usually, sometimes, or never

  • Whether Impossible State is possible?

    Opinion

    Editorial: Is the crown worth the sacrifice?

Whether Impossible State is possible?